Meet John Doe
Over half a century since its initial release, Frank Capra's Meet John Doe remains an incredibly powerful motion picture, thanks to not only Capra, but to a great cast and a powerful narrative. But, despite its widespread popularity, Capra was never really satisfied with the ending, which he felt had been dictated by the fact that he and screenwriter Robert Riskin had written themselves into a corner.
With its close parallel to the Christ tale, Meet John Doe practically mandated that Gary Cooper give up his life to resurrect the "John Doe" movement for the sake of all the "little guys" who had put their faith in him. But, the audiences of 1941 wouldn't tolerate a Cooper suicide, and Capra eventually shot six endings before settling on the one seen here. But, the picture was so well received, the New York Critics--who had ignored all of what Capra regarded as his true classics--gave Meet John Doe a coveted spot on their annual "Top Ten" listing. Go Figure. With Meet John Doe, Frank Capra was warning the complacent democracies of the perceived threat of Fascism to his adopted America from both without and within. His warnings initially went unheeded. But only a few months into the release of Meet John Doe, Pearl Harbor had been bombed, America was united, Capra had rushed through the shooting of Arsenic And Old Lace (which had begun December 1, 1941), and was in the Army overseeing the Why We Fight films, the most stunning series of documentaries ever produced.
Member Reviews
Great - FilmJunkie
In 1936 Frank Capra directed Gary Cooper as an average fellow who gets a big break, falls for a scheming reporter and uses his new fame to help the common man, five years later they employ much the same formula in this story. However unlike 'Mr. Deeds Goes To Town', 'Meet John Doe' is the story of a man who wins false fame and is forced to become the voice of the people.
The morality of this film is a much trickier bag than 'Deeds', John Doe just wants to be a baseball player once again, he is a simple man, yes, but he gains the views of the idealistic Ann (Barbara Stanwyck) possibly more out of love for her than his own political motivations.
Yes, it is still a Capra film and thus the good old boy wins out over the political bigwigs, but this is more the story of a heroic woman who must masquerade as a man to get her voice heard. Ann writes the John Doe letter as a protest to losing her job and is thus forced to create Doe due to the character's popularity. One could view this film as a pre-feminist (post-suffrage, of course) commentary on society's inability to listen to a woman's voice in the political arena. Sure, Ann falls for John, but it is her words and her passion that win his heart and spark the nation to join in a sense of community.
Stanwyck is complex and brilliant as the conflicted Ann who is trying to provide for her family, have a voice as a journalist and love the man she has created. Cooper is dopey and sweet as John, the man trying to please everyone but himself. He has the most beautiful eyes in the history of black and white cinema, and his lanky frame allows him to stand apart from the many leading men of his era. They work well together, not because they go toe-to-toe like Cary Grant and Irene Dunne, but because he allows her to be the stronger persona. A very modern take on love.
This is a great Capra film that will go alongside 'Mr. Smith Goes To Washington (1939)and 'It Happened One Night (1934A Great Classic - peacetrain1
This Capra Film is fantastic, I read a review of it in a spiritual newsletter from a good spiritual teacher who died for a cause of writing and getting out a spiritual book. This film was one of his favourites so I had to rent it from zip to find out. Sure enough it left me in awe. It sends a heart felt message similar to the modern day film pay it forward. A movie you will want to watch more than once to grasp the full impact and meaning if you are a seeker of such things. I don't want to spoil the film by saying anything but it is about the coruption of power and the love thy neigbour morals.Needs a new edition - aeg-
Seriously underrated Capra film (in fact, it may be my favorite of all of his films) featuring Gary Cooper's greatest performance. Sure, the film is slightly preachy but its liberal establishment politics are still timely. My only complaint is the cheap-o DVD quality (poor print quality, bad audio transfer) makes me wish for a reissue.
Member Reviews
Read All...
Great - FilmJunkie
In 1936 Frank Capra directed Gary Cooper as an average fellow who gets a big break, falls for a scheming reporter and uses his new fame to help the common man, five years later they employ much the same formula in this story. However unlike 'Mr. Deeds Goes ...A Great Classic - peacetrain1
This Capra Film is fantastic, I read a review of it in a spiritual newsletter from a good spiritual teacher who died for a cause of writing and getting out a spiritual book. This film was one of his favourites so I had to rent it from zip to find out. Sure ...Needs a new edition - aeg-
Seriously underrated Capra film (in fact, it may be my favorite of all of his films) featuring Gary Cooper's greatest performance. Sure, the film is slightly preachy but its liberal establishment politics are still timely. My only complaint is the cheap-o ...